England's Ian Bell says Michael Beer can't be ready for Test cricket after just five first-class matches.
The Australians' shock selection of the spinner doesn't impress Bell, a veteran of 59 Tests.
"One hundred per cent no" is how Bell rates the 26-year-old Beer's chances of being prepared.
Beer only made his first-class debut for Western Australia two months ago and is now in Australia's 12-man squad for the third Ashes Test in Perth starting on Thursday.