Skip to content.

Suicide prevention group takes issue with minister

Updated at 6:09am on 16 October 2009

A suicide prevention group hopes families of people who have committed suicide will be able to share their experience with the ACC minister.

The minister, Nick Smith, said on Wednesday that the ACC entitlements for the families of people who commit suicide were unfair because suicide, although tragic, was not an accident.

Announcing that such families would no longer be covered by ACC, he said it was unfair to compensate the family of someone who had taken their own life but not the family of someone who, for instance, had lost their life to cancer.

He also said that the entitlement system was so attractive that if he himself was given 30 days to live he would throw himself under a train on the 29th day, as his family would be generously assisted by ACC.

Dr Smith has since apologised, saying that that statement was unfortunate.

The director of Suicide Prevention Information New Zealand, Merryn Statham, says loss through suicide is not the same as loss through cancer and they cannot be compared.

Listen to Dr Smith's original comment and apology on Checkpoint

Copyright © 2009 Radio New Zealand

Radio New Zealand Audio

hide window

Audio is categorised based on the frequency of the programme it was heard in. Click on the headings below to access the programmes. If you are unsure where to look, try the audio search or the latest audio page.

Live Audio Streams

Streams are in Windows Media format. Mac and Linux users see our help section.

If you use Windows Vista and streaming has stopped working see our help section.

Daily On Demand

Weekly Audio On Demand

Music On Demand

Documentaries, Lectures and Forums

Parliament Audio

Podcasts & Downloads

Downloads and Podcasts are available on selected programmes. Our podcast page has a complete list of feeds.

Audio Help

News Access Keys

Why does this site look so plain?