When Massey University’s Steve Trewick got a call from the UK to say that a male stick insect had been found he was ‘politely sceptical’ - because it belongs to a group of New Zealand stick insects that is always all female.
But it was indeed the ‘missing’ male – the first one ever discovered in a genus of stick insects known as Acanthoxyla.
Some groups, such as Acanthoxyla, don’t do sex at all – they do virgin births. The females reproduce parthenogenetically or asexually, producing lots of daughters that are clones of themselves.
Other species reproduce sexually, while yet others, such as Clitarchus hookeri do a bit of both. In the warm north of New Zealand there are males and females, and populations reproduce sexually. Further south, where it is colder, there are all-female populations reproducing by parthenogenesis.
The male in question belongs to a species called the unarmed stick insect, Acanthoxyla inermis. The unarmed stick insect has established populations in the United Kingdom, which explains why he was found there.
Trewick says that male stick insects are shorter and much thinner than the females, and “have a knobbly bottom.”
So how does a male stick insect suddenly appear in an all-female lineage?
Trewick explains that, just like in humans, female stick insects have two XX sex chromosomes. But males just have a single X. So, a simple mutation by a reproducing cell that failed to divide properly could produce an animal with a single X.
Trewick says he suspects the male would be infertile – but as it has already died in captivity, this can’t be put to the test directly.