19 Apr 2017

State abuse survivor surprised at govt's stance on inquiry

9:32 pm on 19 April 2017

A Māori state abuse survivor says the government's refusal to hold an inquiry into historical abuse of children in state care is yet another let-down for the victims still dealing with their childhood trauma.

Eugene Ryder was only 11 years old when he went into state care, where he was beaten and abused.

Today, he attended a panel discussion held at Victoria University in Wellington, where calls for an independent inquiry were renewed.

It followed high-profile calls for an inquiry by the Human Rights Commission, Iwi Leaders Forum, Māori Women's Welfare League and every political party, except National.

Prime Minister Bill English has said he doubted an inquiry would achieve anything.

Mr Ryder said it showed the government still did not have his back, just as it did not when he was a child.

"I have never expected to feel any love from the government," he said.

"I was surprised by their reaction given the amount of support and publicity for an independent inquiry.

"I take the current government as somewhat pragmatic and given that yesterday they announced $2 billion going into what I would consider unfair treatment of care workers, that they would take the same stance with those that have been abused in state care."

Since Mr Ryder went public about being beaten and abused as a child in state care, he said a lot of people had been messaging him on Facebook offering support, but also sharing their own stories about how state abuse had impacted them and their whānau.

He described his response as "shock and horror".

Between the 1940s and early 1990s, about 100,000 children were in state care.

Mr Ryder said there needed to be an independent inquiry into the abuse he thought many faced, but he was not holding his breath.

"There is a public assumption that this happened to a handful of children - I think [instead] a handful of children it did not happen to. That will shock the nation."

He said the government was looking at it through a financial lens and would not want to foot the bill if it was found liable for any wrongdoing, but he said it was not about the money.

"All my life I have been held accountable for my actions.

"All I want is for the state to acknowledge and accept accountability for the mistakes that they made."

no caption

Judge Carolyn Henwood Photo: RNZ / Leigh McLachlan

One of the speakers at Victoria University was Judge Carolyn Henwood, the former chair of the Confidential Listening and Assistance Service, whose report highlighted the extent of historical state abuse.

She said it could be the source of many problems in the community today.

"Every day we are very concerned in New Zealand, right now, that we have high levels of child abuse, children getting murdered, violence and domestic violence," she said.

"We worry about what we are going to do about it yet do we really understand the nature of our community and how it links back to policies of the past? Maybe decades ago, that have fed in to this."

no caption

Prue Kapua Photo: RNZ / Leigh McLachlan

Tamatekapua Law principal and Te Ropu Wahine Māori Toko I Te Ora Māori Women's Welfare League national president Prue Kapua said the government's response undermined the victims who have come forward.

"To continue to say 'we are not going to have an inquiry, we are not going to address the systemic issues, we are not going to look at how we can do it better', it kind of undermines where they [victims] are coming from and the efforts that they are doing and what they are having to live with.

"No government should be doing that to people," she said

Cooper Legal principal Sonja Cooper represented more than 700 victims of state abuse.

She said going through the courts for any resolution was too challenging and, without an independent inquiry, the victims had a slim chance of ever getting justice.

Get the new RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs