Our Changing World
Thursday 8 October 2015, with Alison Ballance & Veronika Meduna
On This Programme
- Science of stony soils and water
- How best to invest in science
- Why kakariki are losing their feathers
- Wellington joins 100 Resilient Cities
- Living in the age of resilience
Science of stony soils and water
By Alison Ballance
“We’ve an integrated research project using lysimeters to quantify how our management activities affect both the performance of crops and also how water and nutrients leach out the base.”
Sam Carrick, Soil Scientist, Landcare Research.
What do a 50-cm diameter barrel, a 2-metre diameter sewer pipe and a shipping container have in common? They are all being used to study stony soils in Canterbury, to see how water and animal urine move through the soil, affect plant growth and contribute to the emission of greenhouse gases such as nitrous oxide. They have been turned into lysimeters, which enclose an undisturbed plug of soil that can be fitted with scientific instruments so it can be studied in detail. The smaller lysimeters can even be dug up and moved to a new location, while keeping the soil structure intact.
Sam Carrick is a soil scientist from Landcare Research at Lincoln, and he is involved in a six-year research programme called ‘Forages for Reduced Nitrate Leaching’. The project, which is being run by a number of organisations at the Lincoln Hub, including Lincoln University, Dairy NZ, and Plant and Food as well as Landcare Research, aims to ‘reduce nitrate leaching losses by 20 percent by delivering proven, adoptable and profitable pasture and forage crop options.’
A number of lysimeters have been installed on research farms around Lincoln. One contains 24 of the smaller lysimeters, and has a moveable greenhouse that can slide over the lysimeters to keep them dry during a rain storm. This is because irrigation rates are being studied in this experiment, and natural rain would upset the calculations. Different kinds of irrigators deliver water at different rates, and even a centre pivot irrigator delivers differing amounts of water at different points along the irrigator. Sam says it’s important to know the best flow rate and the optimum interval to irrigate at to ensure that the greatest amount fo water stays in the soil and doesn’t flush straight through.
In other experiments lysimeters are variously treated with a nutrient-rich amount of water that mimics a natural urine patch left by a cow.
The 50-cm diameter barrels are the same size as an average urine patch, so some lysimeters can be treated while others are left as controls.
The exercise is being scaled up using the Christchurch rebuild-inspired lysimeters made from a piece of sewer pipe and the shipping container. These lysimeters are large enough to grow crops on, and a number of urine patches can be applied across the surface. Previous research has shown that in the course of a year about cows deposit urine on about half a paddock.
How best to invest in science
We should fund research.
But trying to choose the best
Doesn't work too well.
Haiku summary of a Motu research project evaluating the Marsden Fund
This week, the government released its science funding strategy, setting out a long-term vision for the science system and a guide for future investments.
The National Statement of Science Investment (NSSI) lays out several key goals: to simplify contestable funding processes, to review the core funding for Crown Research Institutes, to “refresh” the Health Research Council and to introduce annual performance reports evaluating the science system.
At the NSSI launch, science minister Steven Joyce also stressed the government’s intention to increase public funding of science. “We have made a commitment to grow our investment in science further to 0.8 per cent of GDP and include more ideas-led discovery research, which is likely to generate substantial long-term benefits for New Zealand.”
New Zealand spends less money on research, relative to its size, than many other countries in the OECD, and the government’s goal of expanding public funding of science would narrow this gap. But the intention comes with the caveat that it would require a balanced budget.
Adam Jaffe, the director of Motu Economic and Public Policy Research, says raising public investment from about 0.5 per cent of GDP currently to 0.8 per cent would be significant, but it should not hinge on favourable fiscal conditions.
That caveat means that we don’t quite know if or when it’s going to happen. The current government seems quite focused on balancing the budget so the money would have to come from somewhere else. What’s unfortunate about that is that the evidence both internationally and to some extend from New Zealand is that the return on an increased investment in science would be very beneficial for New Zealand.
Adam Jaffe, Motu
He says conditioning the goal on achieving a budget surplus doesn’t make sense from an economic perspective.“If the return is high you’d like to make that investment even if you have to borrow money to do it because the return is going to be there.”
Adam Jaffe says he is not advocating a crash programme because the science system could not support that, but he would like to see a commitment to a long-term gradual increase. “Something like 5 per cent over inflation per year for the next 10 years, that would be the kind of programme that would build the infrastructure and the science system that we need in New Zealand.”
Nicola Gaston, the president of the New Zealand Association of Scientists and a principal investigator at the MacDiarmid Institute for Advanced Materials and Nanotechnology, welcomes the NSSI as a great improvement on the draft document which was released a year ago.
“Some of the recommendations made by the NZ Association of Scientists (as well, no doubt, as by others) appear to have been taken seriously: this is reflected, for example, in the stated intent to increase levels of investigator-led funding both through the Marsden Fund and through MBIE mechanisms.”
But she says nothing has been done to address the severe shortage of postdoctoral fellowships in New Zealand.
“This government cut 90 post-doctoral fellowships in 2010 after officials made a simple mathematical error in a briefing document to the then minister, Wayne Mapp. The draft Statement mentioned post-doctoral fellowships 10 times, and sector submissions made more than 50 mentions of their concerns about a lack of funding for postdocs. Yet this final cut fails to mention postdoctoral fellows at all. This is really very disappointing.”
He says he’s found little new thinking or new policy in the NSSI document.
The priorities still seem to lie principally in seeing science as a route to economic growth, with the nods to health and environmental research focussing on how they too can help grow the economy.
Shaun Hendy, Te Punaha Matatini
Adam Jaffe welcomes the intention to improve evaluation and performance measurement in the science sector. Last week, Motu released a study that evaluated the efficacy of the Marsden Fund and found that grant recipients clearly benefit.
“We find that funding is associated with a significant increase in researchers’ scientific output and the apparent impact of their output as measured by subsequent citation.”
However, another result of the study shows that the selection process, in which expert panels rank the proposals, is not predictive of subsequent success, which implies that if the unfunded projects could have been funded, the benefit wold have been as great as for the projects that were actually funded.
“This means there is no reason to expect diminishing returns if Marsden funding were increased.”
Why kakariki are losing their feathers
By Alison Ballance
“For the last few years we’ve seen quite a few rather bald and mangy looking kakariki, and we’ve discovered it’s a skin mite. The mite is microscopic, and it burrows around the feather follicle and pushes the feathers out.”
Emma Wells, bird keeper, Auckland Zoo
“The reality is we seeing more and more disease in wildlife. Because of the pressures wildlife is under animals are increasingly stressed and they’re succumbing to things that historically they might have been able to fight off.”
Dr Bethany Jackson, wildlife vet, Murdoch University.
Kakariki or red-crowned parakeets on Tiritiri Matangi Island, an open sanctuary in the Hauraki Gulf, have a problem. Many of them are losing feathers, and in the worst cases birds are becoming quite bald.
The culprit was identified as a mange mite by Australian wildlife vet, Dr Bethany Jackson, from Murdoch University. A few years ago Bethany investigated the problem as part of the PhD research, and since then she has worked with Auckland Zoo in an ongoing disease screening programme on the island.
Every spring a team visits the island to catch kakariki in mist nets, and assess their health status. The birds are banded, measured and weighed, blood samples are collected for disease screening, and feather loss is estimated. Over the week the zoo staff and volunteers are on the island they usually manage to sample about 70 birds. This spring more than half of the birds studied had mange.
Auckland Zoo keepers Emma Wells and Nat Sullivan also carry out a nesting study, following breeding success in fifty kakariki nests.
“What we want to know is how the mange is related to weather patterns and to food availability,” says Emma. “We also want to know if it’s causing issues with breeding. Last year, for instance we had a really low chick survival, with no survivors.”
Emma says that it seemed this low chick survival was related to poor food availability, and that the mange is worse during a poor food year.
The team take photographs of each bird, and by comparing photos of birds that have been caught more than once, over several years, there is evidence that some birds can recover from a bad case of mange.
Bethany says that the mite affects adult birds, but not chicks.
“We also know that kakariki on Little Barrier Island carry the mites, too, although they were looking normal when we sampled them,” says Bethany. “So we suspect this mite could be quite widespread in parakeets in New Zealand.”
Bethany says that it’s important to establish baseline disease surveillance for animals to set a benchmark for what’s ‘normal’.
“While disease is something that has always been part of wildlife ecology, the rate of change in terms of habitat change, climate change means wildlife is under increasing pressure from all directions, including predators,” says Bethany. “And really disease is just another threat we want to be keeping tabs on, and seeing if there’s something new coming into the country. And the reality is we seeing more and more disease in wildlife.”
Tasmanian devil facial tumour, chytrid fungus in frogs and a new fungus infecting salamanders are example of recent disease outbreaks, and Bethany says the growing international trade in wildlife increases the chances of diseases spreading.
Last year Our Changing World joined Auckland Zoo as they released captive-bred wetapunga, or giant weta, on Tiritiri Matangi Island.
Wellington joins 100 Resilient Cities
The way we define urban resilience is the ability of a city to not just survive but thrive in the face of shocks and stresses.
Nicola Thomson, 100 Resilient Cities
Wellington’s Lyall Bay is a favourite spot for surfers – and when the surf is up, the waves pound the beach with force.
At one end of the beach, there’s Surfers’ Corner, a small car parking area that was initially constructed to sit two metres above the beach. But within a short time, the wave action dumped so much sand against the car park's ocean-facing wall that it’s now only barely above the beach and the ocean regularly spills over and erodes the asphalted surface.
Myfanwy Emeny leads the urban ecology group at the Wellington City Council, and for her team, this is one of the challenges they face as they consider options for making the capital city’s coastline more resilient.
One of the decisions we have to make about this area is should we actually retreat from this car park and move it back closer to the road and replant the dunes in order to better protect the road and the infrastructure behind it.
Further along the beach dunes that have been planted with native sand-binding plants act as shock absorbers. They stand up to the impact and power of the waves and allow sand to be shifted around. “It’s a really effective mechanism to protect coastline.”
Along this part of Wellington’s coastline, the ocean already regularly spills over onto the road, taking logs and rocks with it. “That’s exactly what we’re trying to avoid in the future by looking at some medium to long-term solutions for Lyall Bay and the rest of our coastline as well.”
Wellington’s mayor Celia Wade-Brown says urban resilience is a big issue for the capital, which faces natural hazards such as earthquakes as well as longer-term impacts from environmental, social and economic changes.
“Whether it’s more refugees or sea level rise, it doesn’t happen overnight but has an impact on planning. We need to bring that together so it’s not just a central and local government issue, but businesses, communities, families and individuals as well.”
Wellington recently joined a global initiative of 100 Resilient Cities, which was launched by the Rockefeller Foundation in 2013. Last week, urban planners, hazards scientists and policy makers came together at a workshop to discuss a strategy to turn the capital into a more resilient city.
One of the speakers was Nicola Thomson, an associate director for 100 Resilient Cities. She says the programme was launched to help cities around the world to build natural, social and economic resilience in the face of challenges of the 21st century.
The way we define urban resilience is the ability of a city to not just survive but thrive in the face of shocks and stresses. Shocks are traditional disasters … a disease outbreak, an earthquake, a global financial crisis, but we also recognise that it’s equally important that a city builds resilience to stresses, which are things that are happening in a city constantly or on a cyclical basis that are actually weakening the fabric of the city.
This podcast highlights the issues for Wellington and features resilience planners from other cities that are already part of 100 Resilient Cities.
Living in the age of resilience
French experts Pierre Ducret and Lucile Schmid discuss the social impacts of climate change and the challenges in building a fair, low-carbon economy.
Bird of the Year Competition 2015
'Vote Albatross' is the cry from Our Changing World producer Alison Ballance, who is campaign manager for Albatross in this year's Bird of the Year competition.
This is the 11th year of the competition, organised by Forest and Bird to highlight some of New Zealand's native birds. It was first won by tui, and since then it has been won by fantail, grey warbler, kakapo, kiwi, kakariki, pukeko, falcon and mohua. Last year the competition was for Seabird of the Year and it was won by a coastal species, the fairy tern.
Alison reckons that since New Zealand is albatross capital of the world, and since a true ocean-going seabird has never won, it's about time the magnificent albatross was a winner.
Voting is open until 5pm on Sunday 25 October, and a reminder that after you vote you need to click the confirmation email that is sent to you.